Have Extra Cash at Closing? Should You Pay Points or Put More Down?
By Mark Jost, NMLS #150914 · Published
You saved more than you need for closing. Nice work. Now you have a choice to make. You could pay points to get a lower rate. You could put more money down so you borrow less. Or you could keep the cash in the bank. Each choice can lower your costs in a different way. Here is how to compare them, with a free calculator to help.
Choice 1: Pay points for a lower rate
A discount point is a fee you pay at closing. In return, the lender gives you a lower interest rate. One point costs 1/100 of your loan amount. On a $300,000 loan, one point costs $3,000.
How much one point lowers your rate is not set. It changes by lender, by loan, and by day. So the only way to know what points will do for you is to get real quotes. Ask for two quotes on the same day for the same loan: one with no points and one with points.
The cost of points shows up on page 2 of your Loan Estimate, in section A. The rate is on page 1.
Choice 2: Put more money down
A bigger down payment means a smaller loan. A smaller loan means a lower monthly payment and less interest over time. You also start with more equity in your home. Equity is the part of the home you own outright.
For some buyers, putting more down has another perk. On many conventional loans, you pay for private mortgage insurance if you put down less than a set amount. Putting more down can lower that cost, or even get rid of it. Ask your loan officer if you are close to that line.
Choice 3: Keep the cash
Don’t skip this one. New homes come with surprises. The water heater dies. The yard needs work. You need a couch. Money in the bank is there when life happens.
Some loans also want to see savings left over after closing. These savings are called reserves. Spending every dollar at closing can leave you with no cushion at all.
How to compare the first two choices
Start with points. Type your two quotes into our Discount Points Calculator. It shows what the points cost, how much lower your payment is, and how many months it takes to break even. Break-even is the month when your savings finally cover what you paid.
Here is a made-up example to show the math. Say points cost $4,000 and lower your payment by $65 a month. Divide $4,000 by $65. You get about 62 months, or a little over 5 years. Stay longer than that, and the points pay you back. Move sooner, and they cost more than they save.
Next, ask your loan officer what the same $4,000 would do as extra down payment. It will lower your payment too, often by less each month than points would. But that money becomes equity you can get back when you sell. Money spent on points does not come back.
When each choice tends to win
- Points may win if you expect to live there and keep the loan well past your break-even month.
- More down may win if it lowers or removes mortgage insurance, or if you might sell in a few years and want that money back as equity.
- Keeping cash may win if your savings would be thin after closing, or if you know big repairs are coming.
- A mix can work too. You do not have to pick just one. Some buyers split the extra money.
Will you refinance later?
This matters more than most people think. If rates drop and you refinance, your old loan gets paid off. The savings from your points stop that day. If you think you might refinance in a few years, points are a harder sell. A bigger down payment still helps you, since the equity stays with you.
Can the seller pay for points?
Sometimes, yes. A seller credit can often go toward closing costs, and points can be part of that. Each loan type limits how much the seller can pay. If you are buying, read our guide on asking the seller to help with closing costs. Then ask your loan officer what fits your loan.
A quick word on taxes
The IRS says points paid on a loan for your main home may be tax deductible in some cases. The rules are specific. Talk with a tax professional about your own situation before you count on it.
Common questions
Is it better to pay points or put more money down?
It depends on how long you will keep the loan. Points can save more each month if you stay past the break-even month. More down builds equity you get back when you sell, and it can lower mortgage insurance.
How do I know if paying points will pay off?
Divide the cost of the points by how much they lower your monthly payment. That tells you the break-even month. Our Discount Points Calculator does the math for you.
Do I get my money back if I sell after paying points?
No. Points are a cost you pay for a lower rate. If you sell or refinance before the break-even month, you paid more than you saved.
Want to see your real numbers?
As a broker, we can shop your loan and show you quotes with and without points, side by side. Reach out through our contact page to talk with Mark. You can also start an application online.
Sources
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: How should I use lender credits and points?
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Understand your Loan Estimate
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: How does my down payment affect my mortgage?
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is private mortgage insurance?
- IRS: Topic no. 504, Home mortgage points
This article is general information, not a loan offer or legal advice. Every loan depends on credit, income, and property review. Mark Jost, NMLS #150914. Heathrow Mortgage, Company NMLS #1849599. Equal Housing Opportunity.
